“Where did they go?”

Until they were shot where did they stay? Strangely when the camp came online the following year it was full of Jews. That sort of counteracts your statements.

WHERE DID WINSTON CHURCHILL GO?

Philomena Cunk deconstructs Churchill’s legacy and with the help of Dr. Peter Catterall (historian at the University of Westminster) starts the legend that no-one knows where Churchill went either. 🙂

But all the Jews were not shot just over half of them. It begs the question of what happened to the other half. There was a judenlager attached to the Konzentrationslager which defies the pathetic explanation that all were shot. There is no evidence of this just assumptions based on assumptions.

You are just quoting the narrative from Yad Vashem or whatever; this is not needed. If 100 thousand Jews managed to flee the Russians then those that remained were likely to be red Army or NKVD to cause mayhem. This happened with fires and bombs going off killing German soldiers.  If so the Germans were justified in shooting them.  I am sure you are aware of the "Socks of Stalin" given to soldiers of the Wehrmacht in other places.

I doubt that many remained. How was the order to assemble at Babi yar be given, posters put around town? This is NKVD propaganda.

Shooting of partisans, perhaps jewish partisans but terrorists.

It is the elephant in the room for revisionism. Not being able to evidence what did happen to those not gassed or killed in mass shootings undermines revisionist claims they were not gassed or shot.



The question "where did they go?" starts at the death camps and revisionists cannot evidence something other than mass gassings took place inside those places and that there were regular mass transportations back out of the camps. Occasional transports of people to other camps in Poland is evidence of the selection process, whereby the Nazis did not kill when they needed workers.



The claim of a mass cover up of what happened, is an incredible claim that needs an incredible level of evidence. The idea that the Nazis accepted punishment for something they did not do, and that it was possible to hide all the evidence of millions of Jews not being killed, is something that needs revisionists to prove. If they had not been killed, then by the end of the war, there would have been millions of Jews being liberated. Instead the Soviets found largely empty camps and ghettos and the largest single liberation was Bergen_Belsen, which had c60,000 prisoners, not all of whom were Jewish.

If the Nazis had not been gassing and mass shooting, then instead of closing all the ghettos by the autumn of 1944, they would have been opening more and more and had millions of Jews in captivity. If that had happened, it would have left a lot of evidence, impossible to hide.



True, they had an interest in hiding their theft. They also had an interest in denying they had been mass murdering Jews. Plenty of Nazis accused of such murders were safe in South America for decades after the war. Why did they come forward and put the record straight? When Nazis were tried in Germany for the mass murders, why did they not present the evidence as to what did happen? It is normal when someone is accused of a crime and they have evidence it was not them, to disclose that evidence.



That is not true, they were mass murdered at named sites, primarily in eastern Europe.



There has been disagreement as to how many were killed, not that they were killed and what happened. That does not mean historians do not know where they went.



There is ample evidence of large areas of disturbed ground at the AR camps containing cremated remains.



Where are claims being made by historians that almost all the Jews were killed? Any source that claims that the Nazis killed almost all the Jews is wrong.



The Jewish population in Europe was estimated at 10.37 million in 1937 by Korherr. Other estimates have it at 9.5 million (Pew Research Centre). Historians are in broad agreement that 5-6 million died. Korherr reported that the Jewish population had dropped by 4 million by the start of 1943. Pew estimate it dropped by 5.7 million by 1945. That leaves 3.8 million at least survived. Compensation claims can be made multiple times by one person, which is why the figures do not tally.

That the Nazis chief statistician estimated the drop as 4 million by the start of 1943, is in itself damning evidence.

You have failed to evidence what happened to the Jews of Kiev, if they were not shot at Babi Yar and previously you have failed to evidence what happened to those you claim were not gassed at the AR camps and A-B.

Since you have no evidence to contribute to the debate, I suggest you drop out.