General Critique of Nessie's Stock Arguments

Not at all. The evidence of gassing or a holocaust has not been proven beyond reasonable doubt.

This is the information that people like this poster have expounded for years. There is continued use of mass departures as some evidential surety and yet the existence of thousands of labour camps specifically for Jews is ignored; there were no mass arrivals. Jews were transported to one of the thousands of work camps throughout the Reich and its territories.

It is hard to imagine any one leaving a "death camp"; this would be like saying sheep went to the abbattoir and then allowed to graze fields kilometres away.  In that list which is virtually unreadable there is only a mention of TI. This poster is well aware that there were a number of camps in the area. In fact it is likely that the current TII was the judenlager of TI. I will remind people that Kosow Podlaski a few km away was designated as an extermination facility by US military intelligence.


The only evidence is that these people were on a train destined to Treblinka station with multiple stops on the way at Labour Camps and railway junctions. It is a leap of faith to claim all these people arrived at the station. Whether they went to TI, Kosow Podlaski or Treblinka B is of no concern.


Using Wiki as a source of information is fine, but that data could be written by anyone. It can be altered at will. It is interesting that Fahrplananordnung Nr. 562 is used as a source of information; no images can be found to verify this. However, other Fahrplananordnung are mentioned which supports significant stops at labour camps.






Please use the proper embed codes when pasting urls. I notice amongst the list names like Yankel Wiernik. All of these people survived the place. Lets examine how they survived. The following is typical:

Henryk PoswolskiAs for my survival, I owe it to a person from among the Jewish laborers, about 40 years old, who came up to me in the undressing courtyard and whispered: “You are a bricklayer and a stove-fitter.”

It also seems that the commandant was busy selecting labourers every day; on 10 Sept 80 selected, Oct 1, 20 selected, 2 October 20 selected, 12 october 30 selected. All these witnesses managed to survive until the uprising. They were all interviewed by judge Z. Łukaszkiewicz of the
Main Commission for the Investigation of Nazi Crimes in Poland a subservient organization of the Soviet Extraordinary State Commission for the Establishment and Investigation of the Atrocities of the German Fascist Invaders and Their Accomplices and the Damage They Caused to Citizens, Collective Farms, Public Organizations, State Enterprises and Institutions of the USSR (ChGK).

It is likely that all of the statements were written by others to support the Soviet propaganda.

When one reads stories of children beheaded or smashed against walls the validy of such testimony should be seriously questioned.

Especially at Sobibor where the majority left the camp after selection. According to the witnesses only the decrepit were euthanized.


Once again an unrelated discussion on a Belzec transport by a guard is used somehow to support mass arrivals at TII. The only evidence is that compiled by a Polish Judge. There is little evidence all of those people even existed.


There are no fahrplananordnung for Belzec transports. One of the camps en route was Skarżysko-Kamienna run by HASAG producing TNT. They had 8 thousand Jewish workers. Here is a list of the Zwsangarbeitlager für Juden in Poland. link




We will examine these individually when I get time. They are likely to all be Soviet Propaganda.

It is interesting to note that the only witnesses to these alleged atrocities were the jews, the inmates themselves. In other major events a plethora of other people are spoken to, independent people. Marian Olszuk was a Polish worker who had dealings with this TIi and noticed nothing untoward except a bad smell.

I was looking at Nessie's brief posting career over at CODOH.  Here is his 2012 reply to the topic "What made you first question the holocaust?"



Lol, he's just totally lying and pretending like he's a revisionist (or at least questioning).