Mass graves

If you saw a photo of a core sample, you would not know what you were looking at. You would not be able to tell what was what. Hence the need for diagrams, identifying the various layers.



How is finding large ground disturbances in the areas of the camp where witnesses said graves were dug, not consistent?



Mattogno referenced that report. Are you claiming he lied? How is your Polish?



Stop pretending there is no evidence of mass graves.

Nessie wrote:

The irregular pits found at Treblinka were NOT consistent in either shape or size with the graves described by the alleged eyewitnesses. Nessie seems incapable of grasping the scale of the graves needed to contain the entire population of a city the size of San Francisco. It's as though CS-C found proof that a little boy rode his tricycle around the block and Nessie says, "See, CS-C found evidence that the little boy rode his tricycle to the moon".

My Polish is non-existent and thank you for applying the fallacy of an appeal to authority for me. It's not necessary for me to blindly agree with everything Mattogno wrote. At any rate, show me where Mattogno states that the mass graves of Treblinka have been found by CS-C.

Stop pretending that the irregularly shaped pits discovered by CS-C were capable of containing ~700,000 cadavers or were in any way related to the pits described by the alleged eyewitnesses.

What has been found by the camp surveys is consistent with the original graves being dug into to get bodies, the mixing and reburying of cremains and earth, covering over the site, demolishing buildings and burying everything except a couple of buildings for a guard, the post-war grave robbing and then in the 1960s, tidying the site and building a large memorial.

With all of that activity, it is no wonder neatly outlined rectangular ground disturbances have not been found.



What you have failed to take into account, is that by burying naked bodies, those bodies get compressed under the pressure of more bodies piled on top, into a mass of decomposed remains. The bodies buried at Katyn were clothed, but still showed how pressure causes the remains to be compressed. Far more bodies fit into a certain space that you think possible.



You are dodging that Mattogno reported that there was forensic testing of remains from Sobibor and they were found to be human.



Considering how much of TII could not be surveyed, due to the memorial, what was found is large areas of disturbed ground that proves the Nazis did a lot of digging at TII. If the memorial was not there, more disturbed ground would be found, as the existing areas are right next to the memorial. What has been found backs up witness claims of mass graves, stop pretending it does not.

Nessie is just flat lying about the evidence for mass graves. There are NO mass graves as described by the alleged eyewitnesses whether there were five graves, eleven graves or an unknown number of graves, CS-C may very well have found some pits at Treblinka but NOT anything even faintly resembling the volume necessary to contain the entire population of San Francisco.

Nessie wrote:

Nessie claims that the exhumations and mixing and reinterring of the cremains somehow shrunk the original graves. That claim is preposterous on a scale that leaves me gobsmacked.

The bodies at Katyn were discovered by the Germans in April, 1943. They had been buried for almost 3.5 years. Contrast that with Rajchman's claim of eleven graves. Bodies were buried for a total of seven (7) months or a grave filled every .64 months or a grave filled every 2.75 weeks. Hardly time for bodies to decompose and compress to the extent that the cadavers that had been buried for 3.5 years.

Quote and link to the chapter in Mattogno's book.

One 17X26 meter pit and some other rabbit holes don't constitute excavations in the tens of thousands of cubic meters. Wiernik's graves are inadequate to contain 700,000 cadavers and Rajchman's eleven graves are far too large to be hidden under the memorial.

Bottom line, despite all of Nessie's weasel dodging about "disturbed ground" no mass graves have been determined to exist at Treblinka. Finito. End of story.