Unreliable evidence

In another thread, Turnagain said "Uh-huh, the Rosenblatts lied but everyone else just "exaggerated", "misestimated", "engaged in hyperbole" but otherwise told the truth. Witnesses are always given lots and lots of leeway in court which always take into account their embellishments. Nessie has an MA and is a trained interrogator and declares that's the way it is. So there!"

Anyone with any court experience, knows that witnesses are given lots of leeway, because witness memory is the least reliable for of evidence, due to known flaws of memory. A court would be very suspicious of witnesses who all gave very precise, detailed evidence that matched perfectly with known facts, as that would evidence collusion and rehearsing evidence.

If a court were to ask 10 witness to say what size they thought a hole in the ground was, the court would expect 10 varying answers. If 10 witnesses were asked how many people were packed into a room, the court would expect a variation in the answers. If 10 witnesses were asked to describe building, a court would expect to get 10 varying answers.

Witness are known to embellish evidence, make mistakes, exaggerate, forget etc, it happens in pretty much every single trial. Only revisionists think otherwise and that if 10 truthful witnesses were asked to say what size a hole was, how many people fitted into a room and to describe a building, they would give the same answer, with hardly any variation.

In any court a witness may say that the car was dark green and another may say blue without being a conscious perjurer. When one witness states that it was a car, another says an 18 wheeler and a third declares it locomotive the lie is given away. Nessie tries to equate demonstrable lies and impossibilities with minor mistakes. Were there five graves or eleven? Were 200 cadavers cremated at a time or 3,000? Did twigs, brush and camp detritus serve as fuel for cremating the cadavers or was there an adequate amount of fuel? If wood was the fuel, where did it come from? Did most say that gas chambers existed? Yes and most swore that the gas chamber was hermetically sealed. Did some say that the air was pumped out of the chamber? Yes, they did. Nessie excuses it all as (heh-heh) just some "exaggerations", "hyperbole" and other assorted bullshit while declaring himself to be the expert on court procedure and witness interrogation. Nessie is full of more shit than a Christmas goose.

You have no idea of Turnagains experience, so please stop making assumptions.  Witnesses are renown for lying committing perjury along with their friends and families.  Despite the judge and prosecuting officer knowing this charges have to be dropped because the cross examination at the time could not expose it.  

The matter could be pursued at a later date but this would seem like the law enforcement authority are hounding people.  This is not in the public interest and bad PR.

Secret Police of course are not bound by such rules of conduct; the Gestapo followed the rule of law, so did the NKVD but they could shoot first and ask questions later.  Most people simply complied with their request; if they demanded the sky was red it was red.   US Military Intelligence were secret police as were the British in war time, which is why thousands of innocent Germans and others were brutally tortured and murdered at their hands (Himmler, Dachau SS); the crimes of the Geheime Feldpolizei and SS are brought up with regular monotony but the atrocities of their allied counterparts are hidden under the carpet.   They had the power to coerce any confession they wished.   The Soviets murdered 15 million civilians post war; I am sure many of those were people who had true knowledge of the holocaust and camps like Treblinka.  Marian Olszuk should consider himself lucky.

Don't you find it strange that mass murderers at these trials only get a few years in jail. A few years for the murder of 850 000 people at Treblinka.



In more modern times, mass murderers get much more:

• Anders Behring Breivik... Murdered... 77 people...     sentenced to containment link
  
  
• Brenton Tarrant... Murdered... 51 people...   Life imprisonment without parole link

Getting back to an AR camp, Treblinka August Miete (life imprisonment..released 1985) at his trial, said:

It is clear that Miete was part of Aktion 14f13. He shot between 3 and 20 people from each transport.

Willi Mentz (life imprisonment..released 1978)

Once again a 14f13 organizer.

Interestingly in the early 1950s, a survey found that just 5% of Germans admitted feeling “guilty” toward Jews, and only 29% agreed that Germany owed restitution to the Jewish people. Perhaps the judges were a part of the 95% that felt no guilt.

Most likely scenario is that the judges were well aware that the defendants were "scapegoats",an example had to be made.
Another likelihood is the formulation of statements which would involve suggestions of "remorse"; admitting gassing etc. Contrition goes a long way for early parole release in all societies. I am sure they would have hated to end up in Spandau like Heß until they rotted.




I do believe you think this dribble is true. 🤤 No one was de nazified.

You have evidence that the courts were all ex-National Socialists and sympathetic to the German defendants?  Well, don't be shy about it, let's see what ya' got.