Clay wrote:
Werd, please show us a photograph where the stratigraphy in a mass grave filled with corpses killed by Aktion 1005 can be seen.
Aktion 1005 was not an alleged order to kill Jews. Please get that straight. It was an alleged order to exhume corpses, destroy them and erase any traces of mass graves.
Now if you're asking for examples of mass graves with corpses in it with likely victims of Nazi aggression, sure, I can point to some. I already have on this board before. I'm sticking with the photos from Barvenko I made in a post years ago on codoh, the photos from Kerch in Mattogno's book and the photos in Debois' book. Let's discuss them below...
Kerch and Barvenkovo
https://forum.codoh.com/viewtopic.php?p=72255#p72255
Those were mainly photos of Barvenko. If you want to see photos of Kerch, please consult paperback 673-678 in Mattogno's
Einsatzgruppen book free online for a discussion. The actual photos of corpses at Kerch are on pages 778-782 in Mattogno's book in the "Documents" section. I'll reproduce them here.
Now if you want to talk about Busk, one of the graves uncovered by Debois, I have discussed it on this board before. Mattogno
wrote an article about Busk and he reproduced some photos from the work of Debois. I shall do the same here.
Mattogno does not contest bodies were in there. He contests HOW MANY.
Another image (Fig. 2), taken from ground level, shows the skeletons in a mass grave.[48] This grave is bigger, with an estimated surface area of approximately 40 square meters. Another photograph depicts Desbois on the edge of this grave.[49]
Fig. 2: Skeletons in a mass grave.
The skeletons are not piled up on top of each other, but rather, randomly dispersed; assuming a density of 4 skeletons every 3 square meters, the 15 mass graves would only have contained 400 bodies in total. If the graves contained 1,750 each, as claimed by Desbois, this would mean that every grave contained 4 layers of bodies. But since they were not permitted to move the bodies, Desbois and his archaeologists had no way of knowing what lay beneath the layer or skeletons they were looking at. So how did they arrive at the figure of 1,750 skeletons?
The answer probably lies in the fact that, as stressed by Prof. Edouard Husson, the above-mentioned investigation
succeeded in confirming the testimony of the witnesses and the investigation of the 1944-45 Soviet Commission regarding the massacre of the last 1,700 Jews.[50]
A “confirmation" discredited in advance.
Now some would contest that these may even be victims of Nazi aggression. I must admit this. Robert Faurisson made a point years ago about the shell casings. They were apparently from German guns. Um, if that's true, then why could the Soviets not have used German guns since Soviets often regained plenty of territory that the Germans took? You don't think Soviets would take German guns and shoot Ukranians or Poles for example? But then we have to go back to eyewitnesses talking about who shot who at Busk. And all of them implicate Germans as the shooters.