Treblinka was three camps, TI the labour camp, TII the death camp and Malkinia a transit camp.
Nessie morphs Malkinia into Treblinka III. U.S. intelligence claimed that T-III was located in Czernony Bor but of course Nessie knows better. Who besides Nessie claims that Malkinia was actually Treblinka III in disguise?
When a witness says he went to Treblinka, but was accommodated for 8 days, that rules out TII as it did not have accommodation for anyone other than Sonderkommandos or the Nazis.
Nessie declares that there were no barracks for deportees at T-II. He has no proof of that but stamps his feet and shrieks, "No barracks, no barracks". So there.
When a witness describes arriving inside the camp at a station and then being separated from the rest of that transport, who went into the station and they were put back on a train and taken to Majdanek, that is confirmed as TII, due to the station inside the camp.
Thaddeus Stabholz was the one (1) witness who described the train station. According to Nessie, Stabholz was the only deportee to transit through T-II because he described the train station. Everyone else was lying about being in T-II because they didn't describe the train station. They must have been in Treblinka III. Of course T-III was actually Malkinia but was actually T-III so nobody had to describe the train station...or something.
You are dodging checking the witness evidence to see which camp they mean by Treblinka...
Uh-huh, It's my job to check and see if the deportees were in T-I or T-III (the T-III in Malkinia not the one in Czernony Bor). I mean "WHAT IF
" the deportees were in T-I or T-III? They "COULDA
" been anywhere. Maybe even East Bumphuk so it's my job to prove the witnesses weren't lying. You betcha', Nessie. I'll get right on that.
Yes there are, the Majdanek archive is how historians have worked out how many were at the camp and what they did. Majdanek was used to process property stolen from Jews.
Nessie blows voluminous smoke and bullshit about the Majdanek archives in an attempt to cover up the fact that he has only 412 records for the thousands transited from T-II to Majdanek. If you have more than those 412 records of deportees from T-II then let's see them.
OK, name and quote witnesses who were sent from TII to other camps. All I can find of those who can be confirmed as having left TII, is that they said they went to Majdanek or Budzyn or they did not say which camp they went to.
Sam Kulawy left T-II with a trainload of men, women and children and went to Auschwitz. Then there are the USHMM records for five deportees who left Treblinka and were sent to at least a dozen other camps. How many other deportees accompanied them is unknown.
It doesn't, it just casts doubt on your claim that he left TII.
Jeezus H, but how many times do you have to be told that the witnesses' testimony is NOT "my claim"? So far your objection to Kulawy's testimony amounts to some people were sent from Malkinia to Auschwitz. How does that disprove his testimony? Why does that make his testimony "my claim"? How many times do you have to be told that if you doubt the veracity of the witnesses' testimony then YOU have to prove that? So far, all you've done is stamp your feet and shriek, posit "what ifs" and "coulda woulda" and blow smoke and bullshit about the Majdanek archives.
They said "Treblinka", but there were three camps, so which one?
Malkinia wasn't Treblinka III. It was just Malkinia Junction. The only T-III was the camp noted by U.S. intelligence located in Czernony Bor. Treblinka I was a penal camp. People were sent there to fulfill a sentence for a crime. They weren't sent there to be transited to other camps. The witnesses from the USC film archives were obviously referencing T-II, the camp they perceived as a "death camp". Your claim that Malkinia was T-III or that T-I was a transit camp is bogus.
Because there were three camps at Treblinka and when a witness described being accommodated for 3 or 8 days, they it has to be one of the camps with accommodation to do that, which rules out TII.
Your claim that Malkinia was actually Treblinka III is bogus. You offer no proof that T-II had no accommodations for deportees. Stamping your feet and shrieking, "Did not, did not" is proof of jack squat.
You have proved nothing. Arguments from logical fallacies are not proof, or even evidence.
The claim that T-II was an extermination facility has been proven to be bogus. Get over it.
Have you searched the Majdanek archives and found no records of clothing and food for the prisoners? Really?
Nope, but Carlo Mattogno has and found records for only 412 deportees from Treblinka. So, either show more records or give it a rest.
Name and evidence those camps.
If you don't want to believe the records from the USHMM then that's your problem, not mine.
Your claim is that they left TII and were accommodated elsewhere. Why is it bullshit to ask you to evidence that?
It's known that at least 12,000-15,000 deportees left T-II for Budzyn, Majdanek, Auschwitz and a dozen other camps. You have produced records for only 412 of those deportees arriving at Majdanek. You have produced no records for their food, clothing, shelter or witness corroboration of their arrivals, yet you demand an itinerary and complete records for the maintenance of the ~840,000 from Treblinka. Just another bogus demand from you.