Turnagain wrote: ↑
Tue Feb 11, 2020 8:01 am
Where is your evidence they were destroyed?
If they weren't destroyed then produce them. If you can't produce them, WHERE DID THEY GOOOOO?
Scroll down to the section on the archives.
There is evidence of daily mass transports of c850,000 being transported to TII, from witnesses and documents.
Treblinka was in operation for a little over a year. It's agreed that about 6,000 deportees were sent in every trainload. That gives an arrival of 2.37 million if there were daily transports. How do you explain your numbers?
List of known transports here;
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_ ... ation_camp
The total is 863,635.
Prove one single mass daily transport back out of TII, with men, women and children who were sent to a camp and not expected to work.
Prove that those sent from Treblinka were "selected for work" and only "work selections" took place. You can't. "Selected for work" is just some bullshit you made up. IOW, you lie.
If you watch the full Hunt videos about the gassings at Majdanek and his claim TII was a transit camp, you will see that the people interviewed stated that they were selected to work on arrival at TII and that is why they were sent to Majdanek and Budzyn.
Like the Majdanek archives, I can show you where the evidence is, it is up to you to then open your eyes and look.
Now, prove one single mass daily transport back out of TII, with men, women and children who were sent to a camp and not expected to work.
Plus Majdanek could not accommodate hundreds of thousands of prisoners.
Majdanek could accommodate a lot more than the 406 deportees reported by Mattogno.
It could accommodate the 12-14,000 we agree were sent from TII. It could not accommodate the c850,000 I say had been sent to TII, let alone your figure of 2.37 million.
There is evidence ONLY of limited work selections.
Prove that deportees who transited through Treblinka were "selected for work". That's for every deportee. Be specific.
I will try and find past posts listing what each witness said. It will take time as this forum runs very slowly. TSSF has various posts about the transports, including this one about our debate here;
https://www.skepticforum.com/viewtopic. ... 51#p689351
"Hunt listed just two "transportees" from 1942, if I recall correctly - but there were none. (Also, neither of these two said they were transported to Majdanek, so there were no prisoners attributed by Hunt to "the period of mid 1942" speaking of being sent to Majdank.) Hunt's recognition of his "1942 problem" is what prompted his requests to revisionists for information on Warsaw deportees through Treblinka to somewhere else during 1942 - and almost assuredly was part of the reason for his disavowing denial. Both individuals whom Hunt listed as 1942 transportees (Grossova, Kulawy) were shown by Nick Terry not to have been so - and Hunt "withdrew" both during the debate in this thread (of Grossova Hunt wrote, "Not mentioned in the video and not included in my estimate" and Hunt decided to remove Kulawy on the basis of Kulawy's Auschwitz tattoo number).
The chronology is very important, as it shows that during the peak of the deportations from Warsaw, Hunt had zero transported on to other camps, and that he included over 2,500 transportees from after the revolt.
Cleaning up the mistakes, eliminating double counts, removing those counted by Hunt who never set foot in Treblinka, addressing the chronology, and fixing other issues in Hunt's spreadsheet gave us fewer than 2,500 transportees to other camps, all in 1943 (out of almost 800,000 Jews brought to Treblinka); contrary to Turnagain's uninformed whining, this is well within what the Düsseldorf court estimated as far back as 1965 ("several thousand")."
I am giving you the benefit of the doubt by accepting your 12-15,000 claim. You also need to explain why you think people were being sent to labour camps, but that was not to do any work.
The evidence is they were gassed at TII. You have no evidence somthing else happened, starting with they left TII.
Your "evidence" that the deportees were gassed/suffocated in the gas/vacuum chambers, buried, exhumed and cremated on the magic Jew barbeque is farcical bullshit. The records of departures from Treblinka no longer exist. Most likely those records were destroyed by the Soviets. If not, WHERE DID THOSE RECORDS GOOOOO?
There is plenty of proof that the gas/vacuum chambers were imaginary along with proof that the M&H dragline didn't dig those nonexistent graves. The magic Jew barbeque is a proven bust. Neither have you shown any proof that those who are known to have transited through Treblinka were "selected for work". Remember, you have...
No cremains, no graves, no holyhoax. Finito. End of story.
Exactly, I have evidence, you do not. That is why you keep dodging the topic.
You have no rational and evidenced explanation as to how the Nazis moved and kept so many people without leaving any evidence.