Page 57 of 57

Re: Prove that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?

Posted: Wed Apr 17, 2019 11:09 am
by rollo the ganger
I would suggest we modify the title of the thread to say:

"What is the BEST EVIDENCE that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?"

That way, rather than being treated to dubious arguments, we can be presented to information that already (allegedly) exists. Those on the other side of the argument can present whatever they feel is the "best evidence" and we can all just take that information for what it is worth.

Re: Prove that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?

Posted: Wed Apr 17, 2019 11:41 am
by Friedrich Paul Berg
I think what we generally want is NOT merely "best evidence" but "PROOF."

FPB

Re: Prove that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?

Posted: Wed Apr 17, 2019 1:53 pm
by rollo the ganger
Friedrich Paul Berg wrote:
Wed Apr 17, 2019 11:41 am
I think what we generally want is NOT merely "best evidence" but "PROOF."

FPB
You are asking for the impossible Berg. Since we all know that will NEVER happen then at least we can find out what makes them believe it. If you want "PROOF" from them then you may as well just end the conversation here and now.

Re: Prove that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?

Posted: Wed Apr 17, 2019 8:06 pm
by Friedrich Paul Berg
Start your own thread RtG with whatever question you want to ask. I like this thread the way it is.

Surely with all the "mountains of evidence" about the six million Jews and countless "eyewitnesses," etc etc--they can PROVE that at least one Jew was actually "gassed" to death somewhere by those evil Nazis?



FPB

Re: Prove that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?

Posted: Wed Apr 17, 2019 8:20 pm
by Huntinger
rollo the ganger wrote:
Wed Apr 17, 2019 1:53 pm
You are asking for the impossible Berg. Since we all know that will NEVER happen then at least we can find out what makes them believe it. If you want "PROOF" from them then you may as well just end the conversation here and now.
There will never be any empirical evidence because the gassing never happened. The aim of this thread RtG is to give the hoaxers an opportunity to present factual evidential proof for critical consideration, not mere anecdotes on the very slim chance we may all be wrong. So far no evidence of this nature has been presented.

Re: Prove that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?

Posted: Wed Apr 17, 2019 8:56 pm
by rollo the ganger
Huntinger wrote:So far no evidence of this nature has been presented.
And I doubt there will be, so... that being the case, there is nothing this thread can accomplish by asking them to prove it. No point waiting for no answer. One might find satisfaction in that but I'd like to hear what evidence they do have, the best evidence, that buttresses their belief.

Re: Prove that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?

Posted: Wed Apr 17, 2019 9:14 pm
by Huntinger
rollo the ganger wrote:
Wed Apr 17, 2019 8:56 pm
Huntinger wrote:So far no evidence of this nature has been presented.
And I doubt there will be, so... that being the case, there is nothing this thread can accomplish by asking them to prove it. No point waiting for no answer. One might find satisfaction in that but I'd like to hear what evidence they do have, the best evidence, that buttresses their belief.
This request for hard evidence is necessary but second best is OK. Start another thread on the best evidence that homicidal gassing occurred. Of course that is inviting the hoaxers such as the Marx brothers as he/they attempted on this thread with the unwelcome abuse. I am not sure if that is absolutely necessary as "flipper" tried unsuccessfully for years to present anecdotes emphasizing minutiae to detract on exactly this subject on multiple other threads. It would not be so bad if the hoaxers could present evidence for perusal but they are all extremely emotional taking this stuff personally, which is why I and others suspect most of them are Jude. What we can do in the absence of an impartial hoaxer is for one of us to act in the role of the "devils advocate". The topic is so important it must be discussed.

Re: Prove that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?

Posted: Wed Apr 17, 2019 9:39 pm
by rollo the ganger
I don't believe our current hoaxsters here on Rodoh are willing to debate the matter seriously or quite possibly are not able to. The Holocaust Community had its opportunity to answer the question mentioned here in the Zundel Trials and even the David Irving trial. They were given the opportunity to provide expert testimony and the best evidence available but failed in that endeavor. The late Professor Faurisson put the challenge out about the gas chambers and it was never met. I doubt if the "gentlemen" from the other side of the aisle in this debate here at Rodoh, or those at the SSF peanut gallery, would be able to do any better than the so called "experts" called in the trials previously mentioned.

Maybe someday, someone, will come up with convincing evidence that people were gassed by the Nazis in the manner and quantities claimed but so far we have nothing.

Re: Prove that at least one Jew was definitely gassed with supporting hard data such as when and where?

Posted: Wed Apr 17, 2019 10:38 pm
by Turnagain
Friedrich Paul Berg wrote:
Wed Apr 17, 2019 8:06 pm
Start your own thread RtG with whatever question you want to ask. I like this thread the way it is.

Surely with all the "mountains of evidence" about the six million Jews and countless "eyewitnesses," etc etc--they can PROVE that at least one Jew was actually "gassed" to death somewhere by those evil Nazis?

FPB
I dunno', the hoaxers haven't even been able to come up with a convincing gas chamber other than ones using an insecticide or diesel exhaust and you blew the diesel exhaust gas chamber out of the water. Trying to find proof that even one person was gassed in such cockamamie contraptions seems a stretch.