Werd wrote: ↑
Thu May 07, 2020 1:06 am
Nessie wrote: ↑
Wed May 06, 2020 4:16 pm
Werd wrote: ↑
Tue May 05, 2020 5:48 pm
My argument is due to lack of sufficient scientific evidence of gassings in the numbers claimed, there were either limited gassings or no gassings. So they are probably missing.
You claim no gassings, therefore they left the camp.
Nope. Not even close. Read again.
If Rudolf was correct, there would be evidence those people left the camp,
Some of them went to other camps for work.
OK, lets break down your claim.
We already know this.
Indeed, we know about the people evidenced to have left the camp, which leaves a shortfall. What about the rest? It amounts to c900,000 people.
Second of all, there is not necessarily going to be an abundance of evidence.
There is an abundance of evidence for the ones we know about. Most were famously tattooed. They were registered to work or there are records they arrived at other camps, such as Stutthof.
There is then no evidence at all for the rest. No witnesses, documents, nothing. The Nazis kept records of the Jews they had painstakingly registered, but there is nothing for the group not selected to work on arrival at Birkenau.
There are also no witnesses, from camp guards, to the prisoners themselves. That is nearly a million people and not one single witness.
One must take into account certain factors. Jews often didn't return to their home country, some of them were moved around by Soviets, some of them changed their names and hid their religion.
That is after the war. You have jumped forward a year at least. First, evidence those not selected to work left Birkenau and arrived somewhere else.
You are too embarrassed to say how many!
They did not reach the number gassed by studying the amount of residue in the krema walls.
Mistake #1 not checking the walls.
The records tell us how many went missing inside Birkenau. Not the residue in a wall.
They did so by checking records of arrivals against the numbers registered to work.
Working backwards from a conclusion. That's always a problem. You know what else is a problem? Creating gassed Jews out of thin air like Danuta Czech did.
Then show me documents of some other evidence that prove those not selected to work left Birkenau and were transported elsewhere. At the moment you have a huge gap that you cannot explain and you attempt to just dismiss those people as missing has backfired, since they go missing INSIDE Birkenau and even more specifically than that, INSIDE the kremas. That is where the documentary trail runs out and you give documentary evidence the highest regard.